The decision

March 20th, 2005

Recently big blue approached me, offered an internship, I accepted, and it was done. We were to be working on Xen doing proprietary value added components. They told me it was pretty much a three month paid interview to see if I was worth hiring once I graduated. I was getting a chance to do some serious low level development and that excited me.

About a week after I accepted with IBM the Mozilla Foundation contacted my boss, Scott, saying they wanted to hire me over the summer. He forwarded the note to me and I replied to Mozilla with:

This situation really puts me in a pickle. In one hand, I have been offered (and verbally accepted) an internship at the IBM Linux Technology Center doing kernel level programming. In the other hand there is this offer… where I would be able to interact with the community directly, instead of through a large cooperation. The community stuff is what I really really enjoy.

I honestly expected them to reply with, “Lets try again next summer”. But instead it was:

It would be great to have you come work at the Foundation this summer. I think I can do a bit better than the offer you received from IBM.

After Mozilla sent me the official offer this situation turned into a genuine hard decision. Do I honor my commitment? Or do I take the risk, blow off IBM, and see what happens? I asked this question to everyone with ears. I asked professors, co-workers, friends, and family. The responses were mixed. As I asked people I noticed more and more that I wanted them to tell me to go to Mozilla. The scale really tipped once my brother pointed out the obvious and told me to just follow my gut. So I did.

After telling IBM about the situation, and sleeping on it for many nights, I told them this:

It’s been a long week. I have come to the decision that it would be more beneficial for me to work with the Mozilla Foundation. For that reason I request to be relieved of my commitment to IBM. Thank you again for the very generous offer.

Then I waited for a reply. After a week of not hearing anything back I got on the phone. Had to call about 5 times, but I finally spoke with my would be manager. I knew at the end it was my decision and I did not need to follow up with him. I was simply trying to make it right. When we talked he did not make the situation any easier by saying, “Well, as long as you are comfortable starting your career like this.” There was no possible way this situation was comfortable, but I made the decision.

Back at the OSL I was told that while they support my decision 100%, I should really take some time to nurse IBM. Well, I disagree. IBM is no baby that needs nursing. Losing an intern (bottom of the food chain) THREE MONTHS before I was even going to start did not even cause a bump in the road for them. Sure, I may never be offered a job from IBM again; however it does not really bother me. I will continue to be professional with IBM but I will not go out of my way to give anyone a back rub (just as before this situation). By the time I graduate I should be at full pace with my own ventures.

The whole situation was a real eye opener. I had to put some serious thought into my future and am very glad to have such a safe, win win, decision. IBM made me a great offer, and I am very very grateful for that. Maybe in 10 years I will be kicking my self over this, but I doubt it.

So far I have learned that most things work out for the best. Furthermore, I have grown to trust my judgment. Even though I will never know “what if” I truly feel Mozilla will be far more beneficial to my future.

7 Responses to “The decision”

  1. Scott Kveton Says:

    I didn’t say that you should nurse your relationship with IBM because they are going to be hurting without the Polvi-nator this Summer. I said that you should nurse your relationship with IBM because it’s the professionally responsible thing to do. :-)

  2. Karl Murphy Says:

    My dad worked for a subsidary of IBM in the 1960s and 1970s. This was during IBMs problems with anti-trust lawsuits and the like. They dropped his division like a hot potato when they saw that divesting themselves of certain programs could placiate the courts.
    What I’m trying to say is, do what you think is best for you. IBM would not bat an eye to dump you with 1 hours notice if they thought it was in THEIR best interest.
    Also, did either of them ask you to sign a NDA? That would be the deal breaker for me right there.

  3. Lance Albertson Says:

    Wow Alex! I had no idea you were getting in such a bind. I’m not sure which way would have been better, but either way, what you decide is best. I had a friend that got an internship with IBM a few years back and that made way for him to get a job later with them. Now he’s gotten sick with some of the stuff going on with IBM and looking elsewhere for a new job.

    I’ve always been leary of working for huge corporations. I generally get the impression of being more of a number to them rather than a fruitful employee. Anyways, good luck with the Moz Foundation! I’m envious of you ;-)

  4. Mom Says:

    I am so glad that you have a conscience.
    After all, life is all about the choices we make and living with the consequences of those choices. So go have fun, make some money (?), meet new people. You have just begun. Always be the kind human being that you are now. The doors will keep on opening. You will be successful in whatever you do. You are an amazing person.

  5. Auntie M Says:

    I think you analized the situation carefully and made the right choice. Always follow your gut feeling.

    As long as you are happy doing what you are doing success will follow.

    I think IBM dosen’t deserve such a creative mind as yours. You will become a big fish in a big pond and I am confident you will take the right stream to get there.

    Go for it Kiddo.

  6. Randy Kalmeta Says:

    Alex, we still think the world of you! It’s tough to lose a great intern, especially when the fish is on the hook :-) Best this summer and we’ll STILL be in touch.

    Randy (IBM)

  7. Auntie M Says:

    Hey Sweetie…I just remembered your birthday…because every year when I have mine it reminds me I missed yours.

    Actually I was peeking in your blog a few days before and read you were leaving the teenage years behind.

    Congradulations on being 20.

    It just seems so easy to remember when I was 20.

    Some advice from an old lady now, time flies.

    See Ya Sunday. Love Auntie M

Leave a Reply